Only Murders in the Building: List of Celebrity Cameos & Guest Stars

Here is an updated list of Only Murders in the Building guest stars. Here are all of the celebrity cameos that have occurred during the three seasons of OMitB, including Paul Rudd, Meryl Streep, and Jimmy Fallon.

List of Only Murders in the Building guest stars

Matthew Broderick: The Ferris Bueller’s Day Off star appears as himself in the seventh episode of Only Murders in the Building, where he auditions for a role in Oliver Putnam’s Death Rattle musical.
Mel Brooks: Mel Brooks also appears in the seventh episode of Only Murders in the Building, where he is shown Facetiming Oliver to discuss the work ethic of Matthew Broderick’s character in the episode.
Paul Rudd: The Ant-Man star not only has a guest role in the third season but plays a very key role, Ben Glenroy, who is the murder suspect of Season 3.
Andrea Martin: The My Big Fat Greek Wedding actress appears in two episodes of season 2 where she serves as the hair and make-up artist of Charles’ TV series, Brazzos.
Mark Consuelos: The Riverdale alum and Hiram Lodge actor appears in the seventh episode of the second season, where he plays Mabel’s father in a flashback scene that shows Mabel’s special connection with him before his death.
Cara Delevingne: The model and Suicide Squad actress appears in a guest role in the second season, where she plays an art gallery owner named Alice, who serves as a romantic interest for Mabel.
Amy Schumer: The comedian appears in the second season premiere as a fictionalized version of herself, who is based in New York City and is looking to develop Charles, Oliver, and Mabel’s podcast into a TV series.
Shirley MacClaine: The Bewitched actress plays Rose Cooper, a painter and the lover of Charles’ father, who pretends to be Leonora Folger, the mother of Bunny Folger, the murder victim of season 2.
Jane Lynch: The Glee actress plays Sazz Pataki, a stunt double in three episodes of the show.
Jimmy Fallon: The popular late-night talk show host appears as himself in the sixth episode of the show, where he chats with Tina Fey’s character.
Ali Stroker: The Tony Award winner plays a big fan of the Only Murders in the Building podcast in the eighth episode of the show, where she demands more episodes.
Sting: The England native and singer played a fictionalized version of himself in the first season, a resident of Arconia.
Tina Fey: The 30 Rock star plays Cinda Canning, the host of the true-crime podcast All is Not OK in Oklahoma!
Nathan Lane: The Broadway veteran plays an Arconia resident named Teddy Dimas, an old friend of Oliver’s and connected to organized crime.
Jackie Hoffman: The actress and comedian plays Uma Heller, an Arconia resident who flips off Charles within the show’s first minute.
Maulik Pancholy: The 27 Dresses actor plays a neighbor of Charles, who tells him that the aroma of omelets Charles had been making reminded him of a woman he knew named Lucy.
Jesse Williams: The Grey’s Anatomy alum plays Tobert, a documentarian hired to film the behind-the-scenes documentary of Ben Glenroy’s Broadway debut.
Linda Emond: The three-time Tony nominee known for her supporting roles in projects like The Good Wife and Gossip Girl, plays Donna DeMayo, the producer of Oliver’s play Death Rattle.
Wesley Taylor: The musical and theatre actor known for his roles in projects like The Good Wife and Difficult People plays Cliff DeMayo, Donna’s son and co-producer of Death Rattle.
Noma Dumezweni: The actress who played Hermoine Granger in the Harry Potter and the Cursed Child play, portrays Maxine, a scene-stealing theatre critic and a rival of Oliver.
Ashley Park: The Emily in Paris and Joy Ride actress plays Kimber, a TikTok influencer who lands a role in Oliver’s play.
Meryl Streep: The three-time Oscar nominee plays Loretta, a struggling actress who is at loggerheads with Ben Glenroy.
Michael Rapaport: The True Romance and Atypical star plays Kreps, a detective investigating Bunny Folger’s murder in season 2.
Amy Ryan: The Office alum plays Jan Bellows, a professional basoonist who dates Charles in season 1.
Mandy Gonzalez: The Broadway actress, known for her roles in Hamilton and the Heights theatre productions, portrays Silvia, Mabel’s mother.
Da’Vine Joy Randolph: The High Fidelity and The Idol actress plays Detective Williams, a detective on the Kono Murder case who had initially closed the case but revived the investigation after her wife started listening to the Only Murders in the Building podcast.